😬 Etsy: What’s Happened To The Handmade Marketplace?

📰 Industry News

• Royal Mail shares edge higher as shareholders receive final takeover offers, with the deadline passing on Wednesday. (CityAM)

• Boohoo has scrapped giving its senior executives £1 million bonuses after shareholder backlash. (Retail Gazette)

• Marks & Spencer has posted a strong Q1, with a 58% leap in profits before tax to £672.5 million in the year to March 2024. High street sales were also up 19.3%, while its Clothing & Home range saw a 5.3% increase in turnover. (The Industry Fashion)

• Ocado strikes a deal with the recently failed delivery service Getir to send communications to its users urging them to switch to its rapid delivery service, Zoom. (Retail Week)

• With Peloton sales slowing in the UK, the company has launched a rental service. Users can now rent the bike for £99/month and a one-off sign-up payment of £200. (Retail Bulletin)

• Over 120 business leaders have signed a letter endorsing the Labour Party’s economic plans for the upcoming UK election. (BBC)

🚗 Cazoo’s Dramatic Downfall: What Went Wrong?

Cazoo, once a shining star in the online used car market, has recently fallen into administration. The company, which became popular during the pandemic, is now struggling to survive. Here’s a closer look at what went wrong for the online car dealership.

A Pandemic Success Story

Launched in late 2019, Cazoo capitalised on the shift to online shopping during the pandemic. Restrictions and a global microchip shortage, which disrupted new car manufacturing, drove up the demand for used cars. This environment boosted Cazoo’s value, culminating in a $7 billion valuation when it was listed on the New York Stock Exchange in September 2021.

At its peak, Cazoo was a household name, sponsoring Premier League teams Aston Villa and Everton, and employing 4,500 people. The platform’s convenience - allowing buyers to purchase, finance, and receive cars entirely online - appealed to a market eager for contactless transactions.

Rapid Expansion and Financial Woes

Despite its initial success, Cazoo's aggressive expansion into European markets proved problematic. Former marketing leader Andrew Francos admitted that the European venture might have been premature. This, coupled with the company’s never-ending struggle to turn a profit, strained its finances. In 2022, Cazoo posted a loss of £704 million, up from £544 million the previous year.

The company’s restructuring efforts, including selling off its European business and switching to a marketplace model, did little to stem the financial haemorrhage. Just two months ago in March 2024, the company saw 728 job cuts as the company tried to stay afloat.

Market Challenges and Leadership Changes

Cazoo’s fall also highlights the challenges of disrupting established markets. While the company forced traditional dealers to innovate, its digital-only approach faced limitations. Consumers often prefer a blended buying experience - researching online but finalising purchases in person. As supply chain issues eased, traditional dealers regained their footing, offering similar digital experiences backed by physical infrastructure.

Key leadership departures, including CEO Alex Chesterman and his successor Paul Whitehead, signalled deeper troubles. By the time Chesterman left in December 2023, the company’s valuation had plummeted to just $30 million.

The Bottom Line

Cazoo's rise and fall underscore the volatility of tech-driven market disruptors. While the company pushed the boundaries of online car sales, its rapid expansion and inability to adapt to post-pandemic market conditions led to its downfall. This case serves as yet another cautionary tale for start-ups aiming to revolutionise established industries without fully accounting for market dynamics and consumer behaviour.

🛍️ Etsy: What’s Happened to the Handmade Marketplace?

Etsy, once the darling of handmade and unique crafts, is now facing significant challenges. After experiencing a surge during the pandemic, the platform's gross merchandise sales have stagnated over the past two years. The stock has plummeted over 70% from its peak in 2021, and the first-quarter 2024 earnings report highlighted another disappointing performance. The company missed earnings expectations, with a slight revenue increase of 0.8% year-over-year, reaching $646 million, but net income dropped by 15.5%.​

So what has happened to Etsy?

The Unintentional Shift from Handmade to Mass-Market

Founded in 2005 to connect artisans with buyers seeking handmade goods, Etsy has seen seismic growth. The platform boasts over 96 million active buyers and 7 million active sellers, however many of these are no longer the small artisans the site was initially designed to support.​

Instead, Etsy is increasingly populated by drop shippers - sellers who list items they do not make themselves but instead, source and ship directly from manufacturers. This shift has sparked outrage among traditional sellers on the platform, who feel that Etsy's commitment to handmade authenticity is waning.

Seller Discontent and Boycotts

Etsy has faced significant backlash from its seller community over the past few years. As recently as August last year, UK sellers boycotted the platform after Etsy increased the amount of sales income it holds back to ensure delivery promises are met. This discontent echoes a larger boycott that occurred in April 2022, when thousands of sellers protested fee hikes, accusing the company of prioritising profits over its commitment to artisans.

Competition from AI and Mass Production

Another blow to traditional artisans is the rise of AI-generated art and mass-produced items masquerading as handmade. Artists face fierce competition from these cheaper, often lower-quality alternatives, particularly from drop-shippers. Despite Etsy's efforts to enforce its guidelines - removing 140% more listings violating their handmade policy in 2023 vs 2022 - the issue persists, undermining the platform's credibility with bother merchants and their customers.​

Efforts to Reclaim Authenticity & Etsy’s Future

Etsy has taken steps to address these challenges, including the introduction of new functionalities and a more stringent onboarding process to reduce fraud and ensure compliance with its handmade policies. Improvements in search algorithms and seller tools, like the new 'Growth Page' and 'Earnings Calculator,' aim to support genuine artisans in growing their businesses.​

However, many traditional sellers on the platform remain unmoved by the efforts of the platform.

While Etsy remains a major player in the handmade market, its evolution has alienated some of its core users. The question remains whether Etsy can recapture its original spirit or if a new competitor will rise to fill the niche of a truly handmade marketplace.

In the meantime, Etsy's financial health is closely watched by investors and users alike, with the company's next earnings report eagerly anticipated on August 7th 2024. Depending on the results, could layoffs ensue? We’ll be watching it closely.​

📜 Google Has 2,500-Page Leak But Remains Silent

Google, a company synonymous with online search, is at the centre of controversy as it remains silent on a purported leak of 2,500 pages of internal documentation about its search algorithm. This leak offers a rare glimpse into the intricate and converted mechanics of Google Search, raising questions about the transparency and truthfulness of the company's public statements.

Key Points from The Leak:

1. Unprecedented Insight into Google Search:

   • The leaked documents, shared by SEO expert Rand Fishkin, outline detailed information about Google's search API, shedding light on data collection practices and internal processes.

   • These revelations challenge Google's longstanding claims about how its search algorithm operates, particularly around sensitive topics and small websites.

2. Contradictions with Public Statements:

   • The documents suggest that Google might have been misleading about certain aspects of its search algorithm. For instance, there's evidence that Google Chrome data might influence search rankings, contradicting Google's previous denials.

   • Another point of contention is the role of E-E-A-T (experience, expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness). While Google downplays its impact on rankings, the leaked documents indicate that author data is collected and considered.

3. Implications for SEO and Content Quality:

   • The leak highlights the ongoing battle between SEO experts and Google's evolving algorithm. SEO strategies, often based on limited public information, might need significant adjustments in light of these new details.

   • The perceived decline in search result quality, attributed to SEO-driven content strategies, raises questions about Google's ability to maintain high standards for search relevance and reliability.

The Outposts Opinion: The potential leak of Google's search algorithm documentation could have far-reaching implications for SEOs, digital marketing, other search engines and Google themselves. But their silence on the matter speaks volumes. As Google continues to dominate search, the integrity of its processes and claims will remain under scrutiny - and rightly so. Watch this space.

💡 Want To Sponsor Hustlers Outpost?

Get your service or products in front of a whole host of readers, including entrepreneurs, online business owners and e-commerce enthusiasts.

Simply reply to this email, and we’ll get back to you.

Get in touch today.